I think you won't like my opinion, but I don't like templatemonster websites that are spread all around the web. I wouldn't use a template that 75% of your competitors is using. Maybe 75% is a bit too high, but still ..
It doesn't give me a good impression, or maybe that's because I've browsed the 'huge template stores' pretty much in the past and know what templates are spreaded alot.
The design itself ain't horrible at all, but in my opinion you can recognize it out of a thousand websites.