Web Hosting Talk : Web Hosting Main Forums : Programming Discussion : WHich One Is Better ?

[kooshin]

hi
am thinking of using PhpNuke for my website and I would like to compare PHPNUKE and POSTNUKE , which one is better?

I don't know which one to use and i was wandering if you can tell me the one you like .

thanks ,

[null]

I never used both of them but used Google to find some results

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&i...KE+vs+POSTNUKE

[kooshin]

hi
thank you for the answer ,,,,,,,,let me see with google

[MGCJerry]

I've personally havent had any problems with phpnuke5.6...

However, since there are dramatic changes between the 5.x and the 6.x versions, I've had to hack mine to accept 6.x modules and such. I find that versions 6+ have tons of bloat, and a bunch of issues.

I've tried postnuke, but I keep going back to phpnuke, and I've seen that postnuke "upgrades" tend to make many modules no longer work without being edited.

I suggest you try both and see how you like them, and make the decision based on what you're comfortable with.

[OUFNecro]

Personally, AND THIS IS JUST MY OPINION... i dont like either... i dont know what it is about them, i just cant stand any site that is built with phpnuke, or any of the other cookie cutter type CMS's... i much prefer to code it myself (granted, i'm quite adept at php/mysql programming), that way you know that it will work, and that any 'upgrades' done will also work, because you made them yourself... as for the modules that are available for them. check out hotscripts.com under the php section, and i'm sure you'll find a script that will do what you want with minor hacking to integrate it into your site..

AGAIN, THIS IS JUST MY PERSONAL OPINION, if you have great success with the CMS' then by all means, use it.

[kooshin]

thank you man , i myself don't like premade stuff but when I compare them , PHPNUKE AND POSTNUKE < i would say that phpnuke is better but anyways , i changed my mind and am not going to use one of them , so maybe latter