So you are calling us theives if we said don't send the server back??
If they sent him the wrong server, that company must learn from their mistakes. Out of anyone, a company, who is suspose to take time in everything before they do something do not suspose to make mistakes in sending out the wrong server to people.
If he calls and tell them he received the wrong server, ok, thats fine.
If he keeps it, ok, thats on him.
Personally, I'll do one of the 2, it all depends on the mood im in. But if you received a server thats 3x's better than your original one, 9/10 you will keep it.. Alot of people in this business would