Hi guys, one of my partner companies is thinking of a new hosting directory, where the non-profit directory buys services from certain hosts every month and posts the results of their experiences in a hosting forum where potential future hosting clients can come to read of experiences related to hosts.

What do you guys think?

This has been done (though that's not to say another site wouldn't be fine), though I'm not sure if people believe the reviews there either. I think a site has to build up trust before something like that is useful.